Assessing NHL head-coaching candidates

Perhaps best known for guiding the “misfit” expansion-year Vegas Golden Knights to the 2018 Stanley Cup Final, Gallant finds himself again on the open market after a two-season stint with the Rangers.

The positive aspects of Gallant’s resume are clear: he’s a three-time Jack Adams trophy nominee and one-time winner, a Memorial Cup champion and has compiled a career record of 369-262-70.

But it’s notable that Gallant has not finished a third season behind the bench of any of his stops as an NHL head coach, leading to questions over whether he is the right coach for a team looking for someone to lead a long-term project.

He’s undoubtedly one of the most qualified names on the market, but there are, as with any head-coaching candidate, some question marks in his profile.

Peter Laviolette (Former Washington Capitals head coach)

Like Gallant, Laviolette is an experienced head coach with an established track record of leading winning teams. Laviolette has led two franchises to the Stanley Cup final since winning it all with the Carolina Hurricanes in 2006 and has won the eighth-most games of any head coach in NHL history. Since the beginning of his tenure with the Philadelphia Flyers in 2009-10, Laviolette’s teams have missed the playoffs just twice. If a team wants a capable, experienced hand to stabilize their franchise and guide them to winning, Laviolette would be an ideal candidate.

But it’s also worth noting that while Laviolette has won a lot of games, playoff success has eluded his teams in recent years. He was hired by the Capitals to bring Washington the playoff success their former coach Todd Reirden couldn’t manage, but ended his time with the Capitals having lost both playoff series they competed in. While his standout resume speaks for itself, Laviolette’s teams have won one playoff series in the last half-decade, which is definitely something for teams to consider.

Bruce Boudreau (Former Vancouver Canucks head coach)

While Boudreau’s tenure as the head coach of the Canucks ultimately ended in disappointment, the 2008 Jack Adams Award winner remains among the most accomplished head coaches still active in coaching today. Boudreau’s .626 career points percentage ranks second in NHL history among head coaches with more than a decade of NHL coaching experience, behind only two-time Stanley Cup champion Jon Cooper.

Boudreau’s track record of consistent regular-season success sets him apart. But while he is an AHL and ECHL champion, his teams in the NHL have largely failed to make noise in the playoffs, save for a run to the Western Conference Final with the Anaheim Ducks in 2015. If a club wants to make the playoffs, though, installing Boudreau behind their bench could be the way to go.

Darryl Sutter (Former Calgary Flames head coach)

Among the names on this list, Sutter has the most championship experience with two Stanley Cup championships on his resume. He has the ninth-most wins of any head coach in NHL history, but after leading his teams to the playoffs in 13 of 14 seasons behind an NHL bench, Sutter’s teams have failed to qualify for the postseason in four of his last six campaigns as an NHL head coach.

The 2022 Jack Adams Award winner is a highly demanding coach who can help win a lot of games, but also can have a corrosive effect on a team’s off-ice environment, as Sportsnet’s Eric Francis reported happened late in his second tour with the Flames.

As Francis wrote: “No coach prepares players as well as Sutter, few work a bench as brilliantly as he does,” but “his tear-em-down, build-em-back-up approach sucked the love of the game out of many players, including franchise cornerstones Jonathan Huberdeau and Nazem Kadri.”

A team looking to compete immediately with its next head coach would be foolish to not consider Sutter for its vacancy, but it would have to weigh the real positives and negatives of his resume and whether his style is compatible with modern NHL players.

Claude Julien (Former Montreal Canadiens head coach)

The 2011 Stanly Cup champion has taken on international duties for Hockey Canada as he awaits his next head-coaching job. He’ll be behind the bench for the Canadians at the upcoming IIHF World Championships in Riga and Tampere, and very well could be behind an NHL bench after that.

Julien helped steward some poor Canadiens teams to respectability and will always be beloved in Boston for winning the Bruins their first championship since the days of Bobby Orr and Phil Esposito. But he also has not been behind the bench of a team winning a playoff series since 2014, and more and more organizations could be opting for younger head coaches. He’s a safe choice for a team looking for a widely respected bench boss, but maybe not the most exciting candidate given some of the other available names.

Rising stars

Andrew Brunette (New Jersey Devils associate coach)

The Florida Panthers passed on Brunette, a 2022 Jack Adams Award nominee, after his team was swept in the second round by the Tampa Bay Lightning. Brunette was then hired by the New Jersey Devils in a move many believed to be succession planning for the eventual departure of head coach Lindy Ruff. However, Ruff led the Devils on an extraordinary year that saw them exit their rebuild and defeat their arch-rival New York Rangers in the first round of the playoffs.

His work on Ruff’s staff this season is another feather in his cap as a head-coaching candidate, and if the Devils are committed to Ruff as their leader moving forward, it’s possible another team poaches Brunette with the hope that he can help lead a third consecutive strong season behind an NHL bench.

Ryan Warsofsky (San Jose Sharks assistant coach)

While Warsofsky, 35, has just five seasons of head-coaching experience on his record he’s among the most promising candidates on the market due to how successful he’s been in recent seasons. After two seasons behind the bench in the ECHL for the South Carolina Stingrays that included a run to the Kelly Cup Final, Warsofsky took the reins of the Carolina Hurricanes’ AHL affiliate, leading the Charlotte Checkers to a winning season and the Chicago Wolves to a 71-25-13 record across two seasons that included a Calder Cup championship. He was also a top assistant for the Checkers during their Calder Cup championship run in 2019.

This past season was his first behind an NHL bench, as Warsofsky took a role as an assistant on David Quinn’s San Jose Sharks staff. While the Sharks as a whole had a miserable season, Warsofsky’s work running the team’s penalty kill drew plaudits as the unit finished as the eighth-best in the NHL.

Spencer Carbery (Toronto Maple Leafs assistant coach)

Like Warsofsky, Carbery is currently on his first opportunity to coach behind an NHL bench. He’s on head coach Sheldon Keefe’s Toronto Maple Leafs staff, helping the team to impressive regular-season records as well as a long-awaited playoff series victory. Before taking the job in Toronto, Carbery was the head coach for the Hershey Bears in the AHL, going 104-50-17 across three seasons.

Carbery doesn’t have championship experience yet like some of the other names on this list, but he did come close with the ECHL’s Stingrays in 2015, just as Warsofsky did two years later with the same club.

Mike Vellucci (Pittsburgh Penguins assistant coach)

The longtime head coach and general manager of the Plymouth Whalers, a now-relocated OHL team, Vellucci has spent the last three seasons as an assistant on head coach Mike Sullivan’s Pittsburgh Penguins staff. He has some championship experience, winning an OHL title in Plymouth in 2007, as well as with the Charlotte Checkers in the AHL and the Detroit Compuware Ambassadors in the NAHL. Vellucci’s best work was likely in 2019 with the Checkers, as that team tore through the AHL en route to a Calder Cup.

He hasn’t yet gotten a shot as an NHL head coach yet, but he was a head coach across different levels every year from 1995-2020. Could this hiring cycle be when he gets his chance?

Mitch Love (Calgary Wranglers head coach)

While Vellucci was a head coach from 1995 to 2020, Love had his first season as a head coach in 2018-19, an impressive 45-15-8 season coaching Kirby Dach and the WHL’s Saskatoon Blades. His time in Saskatoon was certainly respectable, to be sure, but it’s Love’s two-year run as head coach of the Calgary Flames’ AHL affiliates that has drawn the most attention. The 38-year-old former minor leaguer has won an impressive 96 of 140 regular-season games in charge of the Stockton Heat and now Calgary Wranglers, and he has helped oversee the development of superstar goalie prospect Dustin Wolf.

He led Stockton to the conference finals in the AHL last season and now has the Wranglers in the Pacific Division Finals against fellow AHL juggernauts the Coachella Valley Firebirds. Look out for Love as a future NHL head coach, and if he can manage to add a Calder Cup championship to his resume, he could very well be a possibility for the Flames’ current vacancy.

Jeff Halpern (Tampa Bay Lightning assistant coach)

As a player, Halpern played in nearly 1,000 NHL games and by the time of his retirement was a widely respected bottom-six center. The former Princeton University star began his coaching career relatively soon after his retirement, joining the Syracuse Crunch in time for their 2017 run to the Calder Cup final. After one more season in the Salt City, Halpern joined Cooper’s staff in Tampa Bay and ended up contributing to the team’s run that net the franchise two Stanley Cups and three Prince of Wales trophies in three seasons.

Cooper’s Stanley Cup-winning Tampa Bay Lightning staff has already been pillaged to an extent, with top assistant Derek Lalonde now the head coach of the Detroit Red Wings. With the Washington D.C. native and six-season Washington Capital perhaps making particular sense for that team’s current vacancy, it’s unlikely that Cooper’s staff goes much longer without losing another name to an outside promotion.

David Carle (University of Denver head coach)

The 33-year-old Carle has already built an impressive resume as head coach of the University of Denver, despite his relatively young age. The 2008 Tampa Bay Lightning draft pick led the Pioneers to an NCAA men’s national championship in 2021-22, helping numerous players earn NHL contracts.

While this season ended in disappointment with a playoff loss to Cornell, Carle’s tenure as the Pioneers’ bench boss is already opening doors for his future, such as when he was last month named head coach of USA Hockey’s team for the 2024 World Junior Championships. Could a call from an NHL team be next?

Second (or third) chances

Jeremy Colliton (Abbotsford Canucks head coach)

Named as the successor to Joel Quenneville with the Chicago Blackhawks, Colliton’s tenure in the Windy City didn’t exactly go to plan. He was expected to infuse some youth and energy to an aging roster, and the team had the expectation of quickly returning to Stanley Cup contention under his watch, as evidenced by the Blackhawks’ trade for Seth Jones. That didn’t happen, though, and Colliton was fired midway through 2021-22.

A former successful AHL head coach with the Rockford IceHogs, Colliton was hired to coach the Vancouver Canucks’ AHL affiliate, the Abbotsford Canucks, and has turned in solid work there, leading the team to a 40-25-7 record and a qualifying series victory over the Bakersfield Condors. He was once seen as a promising young head-coaching candidate before a difficult Blackhawks tenure soured his standing in the eyes of many observers. Perhaps his strong first season in Abbotsford leads him back into “rising star” territory in the eyes of NHL teams.

Travis Green (Former Vancouver Canucks head coach)

A WHL Championship-winning head coach with the Portland Winterhawks and a respected player developer and AHL bench boss with the Utica Comets, Green had a rollercoaster run as head coach of the Vancouver Canucks that ended near the start of its fifth season. Despite the good work Green did with the Canucks’ AHL affiliate, he was ultimately a casualty of the doomed Jim Benning era, unable to separate himself from the mistakes the franchise is still working to recover from.

A team with a head-coaching vacancy could look at Green and see someone who nearly took the Vancouver Canucks to the Western Conference Final and had a stellar record of balancing winning and player development in the AHL with Utica. While he might need to take another job as a stepping stone before getting another chance as an NHL bench boss, it’s possible that a club buys into Green as a talented head coach who might just need another shot.

Glen Gulutzan (Edmonton Oilers assistant coach)

Unlike Green and Colliton, Gulutzan has actually already received a second chance as an NHL coach. He got that in 2016-17, when he was hired to coach the Calgary Flames three seasons removed from when he was head coach of the Dallas Stars.

Before his tenure in Dallas went up in flames, Gulutzan worked his way up from successful ECHL head coach with the Las Vegas Wranglers to Calder Cup finalist with the Texas Stars to promising young NHL head coach.

Since being fired by the Flames, Gulutzan has been an assistant coach with the Edmonton Oilers and remained on staff even as the team cycled through head coaches, going from Todd McLellan to Ken Hitchcock to Dave Tippett and then to Jay Woodcroft.

Gulutzan is charged with managing Edmonton’s power play, a unit that has stolen headlines this season as by far the league’s best, scoring at a 32.4% rate. If there is a club with some talented offensive firepower but a sputtering power play, such as the Ducks, perhaps Gulutzan could be an intriguing option.

Todd Nelson (Hershey Bears head coach)

Nelson is an experienced minor league head coach whose only experience as an NHL head coach came in 2014-15 when the franchise’s focus was squared more intensely on their odds of winning the Connor McDavid draft lottery than immediate Stanley Cup contention. After serving on the Dallas Stars coaching staff and helping the franchise reach the 2020 Stanley Cup Final, Nelson this season took the job as the Hershey Bears head coach and currently has them in the AHL’s Atlantic Division finals.

Nelson is already a Calder Cup champion, having managed the Grand Rapids Griffins to a title in 2016-17, and could very well add another championship to his trophy cabinet by the end of this season. He has exactly the sort of resume many teams want to see out of up-and-coming head coaches, and this hiring cycle could be the time he finally gets a real shot at being an NHL head coach.